Improper Counselling: Psychiatrist Suspended for 6 months By TS Medical Council
June 8, 2018
Psychiatrist Sona Kakar
Acting stringently against unethical practices by medical practitioners, the Telangana State Medical Council (TSMC) has suspended 3 medical practitioners sand issued a warning to 2 doctors for improper practice.
During a press note released yesterday, Council Chairman Dr E Ravindra Reddy confirmed the suspension of a psychiatrist and psychotherapist of Columbus Hospitals in Begumpet, Dr. Sona Kakar for six months. The suspension comes after one T Harita Reddy filed a complaint against the doctor.
Informing about the case, Dr Reddy told TOI, “The complainant opted for couple counseling for her marital discord, but Dr Kakar had never given the couple counselling and instead has taken a unilateral decision of giving 21 sessions of individual counselling with no positive result.
Harita also alleged that Dr Kakar has not given them couple counselling for which they have enrolled and this lead to irrevocable repercussions on them and cost them money and kept their lives on hold. The doctor has failed to provide them with the video footage of counselling. Due to this unfair and unethical practice, Dr Kakar was suspended for six months.
* EXONERATED *
No Deficiency In Service: MCI Exonerates Psychiatrist Given Suspension By TS Medical Council
By Meghna A Singhania
January 29, 2020
New Delhi: MCI BOG brought major relief to psychiatrist Dr Sona Kakar, who in 2018 was suspended by the Telangana State Medical Council when after going through her matter as well as taking expert opinion the apex medical regulator, MCI found no deficiency in service by her.
The matter goes back to 2018 when Telangana State Medical Council examined a complaint dated filed by one Smt. T. Haritha Reddy alleging professional misconduct on the part of Dr Sona Kakar due to misguidedness for marital counselling. Based on the complaint of the patient, the state medical council removed the name of the doctor from state Medical Register for a period of six (6) months under Regulation 8.2 of Indian Medical Council (Professional Conduct, Etiquette and Ethics) Regulations, 2002.
Challenging her suspension by the state medical council Dr Sona Kakar filed an appeal with the Medical Council of india. The Ethics Committee further discussed the matter in detail and after detailed deliberation, the Committee decided to accept the said appeal.
Further, the Ethics Committee of the Council investigated the matter and recorded the statements of Dr Sona Kakar and expert opinion of Dr Smita Deshpandey, Prof. & Head, Deptt. of Psychiatry, Dr RML Hospital, New Delhi.
The MCI ethics committee further considered the matter thoroughly in various meeting and found no deficiency on part of the doctors. The decision of the council stated
“….the Committee also noted that Dr Smita vide e-mail dated 15.11.2018 provided her opinion in the matter. Further, Dr Sona Kakkar appeared before the Committee on 16.11.2018, the Committee heard her in detail and directed her to submit his statement, to which she complied. The original complainant, Smt. T. Haritha Reddy vide her e-mail dated 15.11.2018 informed that she would not be able to attend the meeting. The Committee deliberated upon the matter at length and noted the opinion of Dr Smita that there was no deficiency of service by Dr Sona Kakkar and that the cancellation of her registration should be revoked.
“In view of the aforesaid, the Ethics Committee decided to exonerate Dr Sona Kakkar from all the charges levelled against her and to set aside the order of the Telangana State Medical Council,” the council
Relieved with the judgment exonerating her, Dr Sona Kakar informed Medical Dialogues team that through various RTI ‘s, she has obtained material relating to the functioning of the Telangana State Medical Council pertaining to her case and will be pursuing the matter further.